Paws Up!

New York Assemblyman Blumencranz has proposed “Peanut’s Law: Humane Animal Protection Act” to strengthen protections for sanctuary animals seized by state law enforcement.

     The lives of sanctuary animals in New York may soon receive greater legal protection.

     A proposed amendment to Section 11-0512 of New York’s Environmental Conservation Law, known as Peanut’s Law: Humane Animal Protection Act, would change how the state handles animals seized from sanctuaries.

     The bill follows the widely reported case of Peanut the Squirrel. Peanut was a rehabilitated squirrel who gained a large following online. During an investigation by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC), Peanut was seized and later euthanized.

  At NHES, we believe wild animals that can survive on their own should be released whenever possible. However, wildlife sanctuaries also serve an important purpose. Animals living in these facilities deserve humane and fair treatment.

 

What Would Peanut’s Law Change?

     One of the first goals of Peanut’s Law is to clearly define what qualifies as an animal sanctuary.

     Under the proposal, a sanctuary would include a wild animal care facility recognized under federal and state law and operating under a valid tax identification number, such as a 501(c)(3).

     This definition is important because it helps determine which organizations qualify for legal protections.

     Qualified sanctuaries would also have the right to an administrative hearing before animals are seized.

A 72-Hour Waiting Period

     If passed, Peanut’s Law would also change New York’s rules for euthanasia following an animal seizure.

     The bill would require a 72-hour waiting period before an animal could be euthanized. The only exception would involve an immediate public safety risk confirmed by a licensed veterinarian.

     During those 72 hours, families and sanctuary operators could file an emergency appeal with the DEC.

     An emergency review board would then examine the case. The board would include a licensed veterinarian, a public health official, and a sanctuary representative.

     Together, they would determine the most appropriate course of action.

More Transparency and Accountability

     Peanut’s Law would also create new reporting requirements for the DEC.

     The department would be required to publish quarterly reports explaining animal seizures and their outcomes.

     If euthanasia and rabies testing were necessary, the bill would also require those test results to be made public.

     If an animal tested negative for rabies, licensed sanctuaries would have the legal right to seek redress.

     These protections were inspired in part by Peanut’s case. The people who cared for him at P’Nuts Freedom Farm Animal Sanctuary had little legal recourse after he was seized and euthanized on the same day. Peanut later tested negative for rabies.

Protecting Animals While Addressing Public Safety

     In a letter to New York Governor Kathy Hochul, Assemblyman Blumencranz said he hopes Peanut’s Law will balance animal protection, public safety, and respect for sanctuary operators.

     The proposed bill could provide meaningful protections for animals living in licensed sanctuaries. However, it remains unclear whether New York lawmakers will ultimately support the legislation.

     In the meantime, there are still ways you can help wildlife in your own community.

     Support local conservation efforts, respect wildlife habitats, and contact qualified wildlife rehabilitators when an animal needs help. Small actions can reduce the number of wild animals that eventually require sanctuary care.

 

August 12, 2022

Paws Up!

NYC Councilmember Robert Holden is advocating to end the use of horses to pull carriages in Central Park with the introduction of Int. No. 573.


What comes to your mind when you think of horses and what they require to live happy and healthy lives? Did grazing in green pastures come to your mind or galloping in fields with other horses? What about when you think of New York City? What comes to mind? Did you think of museums, the theater, delicious food, and crowded streets with honking vehicles? You probably did not envision horses amidst the city life. Encountering a horse pulling a carriage in Central Park may look nostalgic, but these beautiful creatures look foreign and out of place when paired with the city’s busy streets.

Some feel that carriage rides in Central Park are part of the history of NYC. The massive 840-acre park may seem like an idyllic location for horses to spend their days as they clip-clop through the park, but is it? Do regulations exist to protect them? Yes, there are regulations, but are they enough? Some laws include: how long a horse can work, time off, veterinary care, and specific temperatures when they cannot work. According to the N.Y.C. Admin. Code §§17-330(g)(1) to 17-330(g)(2), carriage horses are only allowed to work up to nine hours in 24 hours. When they aren’t working, the horses need at least five weeks of vacation a year “at a horse stable facility which allows daily access to paddock or pasture turnout.” Concerning veterinary care and unsafe temperatures, the N.Y.C. Admin. Code §§ 17-330(n), 17-330(o)(1) to 17-330(o)(2) states that routine checkups are to be done “at intervals of not less than four months and not greater than eight months,” and, they cannot work when temperatures exceed 90 degrees Fahrenheit or are below 18 degrees Fahrenheit.

Recently, in the news, a carriage horse stumbled to the ground amidst sweltering temperatures in August and could not get back up. The New York City Police Department came to the horse’s aide. Upon observation, the cause of the collapse was unknown, but to onlookers, the sight was distressing to witness. Some thought the heat might be a factor or dehydration. After some time, the horse was loaded into a trailer to return to the stable. It is reported that a veterinarian looked at the horse, and the diagnosis was deemed a neurological condition resulting from contact with opossum excrement. This instance makes some pose the question, could this have been avoided? Is it time to stop carriage rides in Central Park?

In a news article last month, NYC Councilmember Robert Holden seeks to prohibit horse-drawn carriage rides and replace them with electric carriages. What do you think about the introduction of Int. No. 573? Please share your thoughts by taking our poll:

Take Action: New York City residents, if you believe that horse-drawn carriage rides should be stopped, please show your support by contacting your city representative today!

 

Red squirrel sitting on a tree stump eating seeds.

Take Action

Contact Governor Hochul and show your support for Peanut’s Law.